K-1 Losses vs. Bank Account Gains: Why Multifamily Investors Are Misreading Their Returns

Multifamily investors often confuse paper losses from K-1 forms with actual financial losses, but these losses signal tax benefits that can enhance wealth.

DC Metrowire Staff
••Real Estate
K-1 Losses vs. Bank Account Gains: Why Multifamily Investors Are Misreading Their Returns

Multifamily investors often find themselves puzzled when their K-1 tax forms show a loss while their bank accounts reflect positive cash flow. This apparent contradiction, says Steven Libman, founder of Investing With Purpose™, leads many to misinterpret one of the most valuable aspects of real estate investing. The confusion stems from a deep-seated association between the word “loss” and financial harm, but in real estate, a K-1 loss typically indicates the opposite.

The mechanics begin with depreciation. The tax code allows property owners to deduct the wear and tear of a building over time, even though no cash is spent on that wear and tear. For residential real estate, the standard depreciation schedule spreads this deduction over 27.5 years. A cost segregation study, an engineering report that breaks the property into its individual components, can identify elements that qualify for shorter depreciation schedules of five, seven, or 15 years. Under 100% bonus depreciation, anything on a 15-year or shorter schedule can be pulled entirely into year one.

The result, according to Libman, is that a property can generate real, positive cash flow while simultaneously producing a tax loss large enough to shelter that income entirely. “When we are trained to hear loss, we think, ‘Oh no, I lost money,’” Libman says. “And in real estate, a K-1 loss usually means the opposite of what’s happening in real life. It just means that it’s a non-cash expense.” The K-1 itself connects the property’s depreciation to the individual investor’s tax return, flowing directly into the investor’s personal return.

Libman says investors most commonly leave value behind by misunderstanding what happens to losses they cannot immediately use. The assumption is that unused losses expire, but they do not. If an investor generates $150,000 in K-1 losses in a given year but only has $100,000 in taxable income to offset, the remaining $50,000 carries forward indefinitely, available to offset income in future years. This carry-forward feature turns depreciation from a single-year benefit into a long-term tax asset. “Those carry forward in perpetuity, so that can continue to offset income down the road, not just this year,” Libman says. “It’s not like if you don’t use it, you lose it. You get to keep it.” An investor who builds a portfolio of multifamily assets over time can accumulate a growing pool of carried-forward losses that continues to shelter income long after the original depreciation was generated.

The ability to use K-1 losses depends heavily on an individual’s tax situation. The IRS distinguishes between passive and active income, and most real estate losses are classified as passive, meaning they can typically only offset other passive income, not W-2 employment income. However, Libman points to a strategy that can change this picture: the real estate professional designation. Under IRS rules, a taxpayer who spends at least 750 hours annually in real estate activities may qualify for treatment that allows those losses to offset other income, including W-2 income when filing jointly with a qualifying spouse. “If you have a W-2 spouse and you’re a real estate professional, then that depreciation can actually go and offset some of the W-2 income because you’re married and filing jointly,” Libman says.

At Investing With Purpose, Libman says the firm runs cost segregation studies as a standard part of the acquisition process, generating the depreciation that flows through to K-1s. The firm treats the resulting tax losses as a benefit layered on top of the property’s standalone investment case, not as a substitute for it. “We underwrite the property as a standalone, and then the tax benefit is kind of the cherry on top,” Libman says. “We never make it part of our underwriting assumptions.” Libman notes that depreciation does not eliminate the tax obligation permanently; there is recapture when an asset is sold. But those who purchase a new property in the same year they sell generate fresh depreciation, creating what Libman describes as a stacked tax benefit that continues the cycle. For those treating K-1 documents as paperwork rather than strategy, understanding these mechanics is a baseline requirement of managing capital responsibly. More information on the firm’s investment approach is available at https://iwpurpose.com/invest/index.html.

Blockchain Registration

QR Code for Blockchain Registration