When a cardiac arrest occurs outside a hospital, every minute without CPR reduces the chance of survival. Many emergency dispatch centers alert trained volunteer community first responders via smartphone apps to provide CPR and AED support before an ambulance arrives. However, the strategy for selecting which volunteers to alert can significantly impact response times, according to late-breaking research presented at the American Heart Association's Resuscitation Science Symposium 2026 in Chicago.
Researchers in Freiburg, Germany, conducted the ALARM randomized clinical trial to compare three alerting strategies: a small geographic circle (about 600 meters), a larger circle (about 2,500 meters), and a "smart alerting" method that calculated expected travel time to the scene versus ambulance arrival. Over seven months, the system randomly switched strategies daily, with neither dispatchers nor volunteers aware of which was active. Results showed that a trained volunteer arrived before EMS in 31% of cases with the small circle, 57% with the large circle, and 58% with smart alerting. Smart alerting also nearly doubled the chance of early volunteer arrival compared to the small circle and was more efficient, deliberately not sending 31% of volunteers who accepted an alert because they would likely arrive after EMS.
"Our study results indicate that how these trained volunteers are chosen and assigned to cardiac emergencies really matters," said Michael Mueller, M.D., senior study author and chair of the department of anesthesiology, intensive care and emergency medicine at St. Josef's Hospital in Freiburg. "When the app evaluated who can actually get there fastest, instead of just who is closest on a map, more than half of patients had a trained volunteer providing care before the ambulance arrived, and often two volunteers instead of one."
The findings are important because current systems often rely on fixed geographic radii, which may overlook volunteers who could arrive faster by car or bike despite being farther away. Smart alerting considers real-world travel conditions, potentially increasing the number of trained volunteers available and reducing wasted dispatches. The American Heart Association's 2025 Emergency Cardiovascular Care Guidelines emphasize that prompt CPR and defibrillation significantly improve survival chances. Research suggests immediate CPR can triple survival rates. However, this study only measured response times, not patient survival, and was conducted in one German region with a high density of AEDs, so results may vary elsewhere.
Mueller noted that "a circle on a map simply cannot capture" the variability in travel time, and smart alerting "separated trained volunteers who could realistically make a difference from those who could not." The authors call for further studies to determine whether smart alerting improves cardiac arrest survival. For more information on cardiac arrest treatment, visit the American Heart Association's Treatment of Cardiac Arrest page, and to learn CPR, Join the Nation of Lifesavers by learning CPR today. The study was simultaneously published in the Journal of the American Heart Association.


